Tribes Prepare to Fight Trump's Plan to Shrink a Sacred Monument in Utah

Photo: John Fowler / Flickr
Photo: John Fowler / Flickr

The Bears Ears National Monument tracks 1.35 million acres across Utah’s vast and rocky landscape. It’s a sacred place for nearby tribal communities like the Navajo Nation or Hopi Tribe. Many originated on this land.

Advertisement

President Donald Trump and Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke have been committed, however, to, at minimum, reducing the monument’s size and, at worst, removing its national designation altogether. On October 27, Utah Sen. Orrin Hatch said that the president told him he intends to shrink the monument by December, along with the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument.

Tribal nations have felt left out of this conversation, and they want to speak to the president himself. They say they haven’t had an opportunity to sit down with him, and they’ve been asking. But if Trump is determined to shrink their monument, that’s a decision they’re ready to fight.

Advertisement

Bears Ears hasn’t even celebrated a year of its designation. Former President Barack Obama established the area as a national monument in December 2016. This came after serious organizing led by the Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition and the Utah Diné Bikéyah, a Native American nonprofit that formed in 2010 to help preserve Bears Ears. However, as Obama specified in his proclamation, this movement to protect the land through federal recognition has been around for at least 80 years, and it doesn’t include just Native people. It includes local conservationists and government representatives, too.

“The tribes are trying to protect that land not only for Native American culture and heritage and to the ties that we have, but for all Americans,” Cassandra Begay, tribal liaison for environmental rights organization PANDOS who had an intense interaction with Zinke in May, told Earther. “They’re trying to protect these public lands for all future generations, for the human race.”

For Navajo Diné member Jonah Yellowman, who serves as the spiritual adviser to the Utah Diné Bikéyah, Bears Ears is home. It’s where his clan’s ancestral roots stem from—his “history story,” as he put it to Earther. This is true for most other Native American members of the Hopi Tribe, Navajo Nation, Ute Mountain Ute Tribe, Pueblo of Zuni, and Ute Indian Tribe—all partners within the Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition.

Advertisement

Members of Yellowman’s nation frequent the desert country of Bears Ears to find herbs, like sage and tobacco, for ceremonies. The Navajo people also use sand and rocks found here for their artwork.

“For my people, my elders, they have these songs,” Yellowman said. “They have these prayers; they have these rituals, all kinds of ceremonies that originated from that area. We’ve been chased off that land ever since.”

Advertisement

Indeed, colonizers and settlers chased the Navajo Nation, along with the rest of U.S. Native American tribes, off their land in the 1800s. The Navajo call this “The Long Walk.” Forced to leave behind their beautiful home near Bears Ears, the Navajo journeyed more than 300 miles on foot to be held captive by the United States Cavalry. Many died on this trek.

The U.S. military allowed them to return to their ancestral lands four years later, but keeping their cultural resources safe has proven difficult. More than 100,000 cultural and archaeological sites dot the area, according to the Utah Diné Bikéyah. They’ve faced significant risk from looting, Ethel Branch, attorney general for the Navajo Nation Department of Justice, told Earther.

Advertisement
Photo: IIP Photo Archive / Flickr
Photo: IIP Photo Archive / Flickr

Now, this flip-flopping in the Trump administration is putting the site’s historic and cultural resources at risk again, Branch said. She visited Bears Ears last weekend and still hasn’t seen a sign signaling its national monument designation. She saw no new material in the visitor’s center, either.

Advertisement

“When I visited the monument and spoke with staff members there, they spoke as though the monument was up in the air, not real,” Branch said.

Concerns extend beyond the cultural artifacts, though. Opening the monument can lead to further exploitation of the land in the form of oil, gas, and mineral extraction. It definitely holds the potential, as the Center for American Progress has outlined.

Advertisement

“Bears Ears has been targeted because it holds resource potential that the oil & gas industry wants to access,” said Native American Rights Fund staff attorney Natalie Landreth, in an online statement. “Opening the monument to development will threaten cultural and natural resources that can never be replaced.”

Tribal leaders are ready for whatever the president chooses to do—especially if they view his next move as illegal. “We would certainly defend the monument in its current legal and valid status, and that might include the filing of a lawsuit, if necessary,” Attorney General Branch said.

Advertisement

Other tribal leaders are on the same page. Shaun Chapoose, who serves on the Ute Indian Tribe’s Business Committee, has been working under the assumption that Trump will shrink the monument. Trump’s comments last week weren’t news for him. What has bugged him, however, is the lack of tribal consultation the administration has sought even amid requests from tribal leaders to meet with them. In the last two months, tribes have written Trump several letters on the matter and have received no response.

Advertisement

Zinke met with the Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition for an hour in May, but they were hoping for more. The Department of the Interior was adamant in an email to Earther that it’s had multiple conversations with tribal leaders throughout the monument review process that launched in April. This process is looking at all monument designations since 1999 that are at least 100,000 acres in size.

Executive Director of Utah Diné Bikéyah Gavin Noyes told Earther that he knows at least 10 local tribal chapters and organizations with which Secretary Zinke denied a meeting. “He never allowed any Native Americans who supported [the Bears Ears National Monument] to meet with him on the local level,” Noyes said.

Advertisement

Tribes have a message for Trump, and that’s to keep Bears Ears protected. But if Trump wants to go ahead and shrink it or remove its designation altogether, tribal advocates aren’t afraid. They’re as ready as ever, said Caboose of the Ute Indian Tribe.

“When it’s all said and done, we’re going to spend a lot of money, make a lot of statements, make a lot of enemies, and it didn’t need to come to that,” he said. “But if it does, the Ute Tribe, we’re ready to fight. We’re not afraid of the fight. If anything, we know how to fight.”

Advertisement

Yessenia Funes is climate editor at Atmos Magazine. She loves Earther forever.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

dnapl
Dense non aqueous phase liquid

Caroline Grambling wrote a nice piece on Bears Ears from a dry sciencey perspective in Science Magazine: “Science and politics collide over Bears Ears and other national monuments

I seems to issue comes down to Trump wanting to reverse everything Obama did, regardless of what he did on the policy front. Here’s a wonderful paragraph outlining the wonders of democratic leadership council (DLC) centrism and going into a negotiation from a compromised position:

Not surprisingly, Obama’s order was a compromise. There’s a large region, called Red Canyon, that was dropped from the final monument boundary—it, too, contains a trove of Triassic fossils, Gay says. But mining companies are interested in its uranium deposits, and pushed successfully to exclude the canyon in the monument. Red Canyon has an existing mine, the Daneros Uranium Mine, which produces a concentrated form of uranium (known as yellow cake) to make fuel rods for power plants. The national monument designation would prohibit new mining operations, and the mine’s owner, Energy Fuels, is seeking to expand the mine from its current 2 hectares to about 19 hectares.

I absolutely love the dry “not surprisingly.” It’ almost like Obama cut his teeth in Chicago. Everything is not surprising.

One way to contest this is to round up all the major nature charities and billionaires. Maybe get TNC et al to work with native Americans to try to get the other 310 million people interested. After a couple of years with Trump we’re all going to become cynical about the plight of others, i.e. “you got your problems, buddy, I got mine” kind of attitude. That was a Tom Waits quote, btw.

Another way is to make this a direct assault on natural scientists including geologists, mineralogists, archaeologist, hydrogeologists, anthropologists, paleontologists etc. Bears Ears is truly a natural wonder. It’s like christmas for those dudes. However, the opposing camp is Ryan Zinke a petroleum geologists and mining geologists may have to walk a fine line here. Sure there’s dinosaur bones - but he/she is being paid to find uranium deposits.

Or just demonstrate the value of Bears Ears is in the natural beauty and that there enough uranium sitting in Illinois at nuclear plants as spent fuel rods to make any mining of uranium ore superfluous.