The Navajo Generating Station's Last Coal Delivery Marks the End of an Era

RIP, Navajo Generating Station.
RIP, Navajo Generating Station.
Photo: AP

In Arizona, former coal workers—many of whom are from the Navajo Nation or Hopi Tribe—are preparing for major layoffs. The Navajo Generating Station is officially on its death bed. The last coal train left the Kayenta Mine Monday, reports Arizona Central, marking the end of an era of carbon emissions and air pollution. It also points to the need to help workers impacted in the transition away from fossil fuels.

Advertisement

The largest coal plant in the West and its accompanying mine have been on the road to being shutdown since 2017 after the utility owners decided that coal was no longer profitable in an energy market where natural gas was prevailing. Since then, leaders in the Navajo Nation and Hopi Tribe have tried to prevent the plant from shuttering by calling on Congress to intervene, protesting, searching for new owners, and suing.

Advertisement

None of these efforts have worked, however. The facilities will be shut down by the year’s end. While the closure of a major coal plant—which emits more than 20 million tons of carbon dioxide in a single year—is a major win for the planet in the age of climate change, it’s awful news for Native American communities that have become economically dependent on the jobs the plant and mine created.

Layoffs are starting this month at the Kayenta Mine, and 265 workers will lose their jobs. Come winter, hundreds more will lose their jobs, reports the Tucson Sentinel. The annual salaries for these workers ranged between $70,000 to $74,000, according to a county report. Many may have to move out of state to find competitive work in other coal mines. By 2021, the Navajo Nation as a whole will suffer a $40 million loss in revenue.

This situation illustrates the need for what advocates have dubbed a “just transition,” ensuring proper protections and training are in place for the fossil fuel workers as the world transitions to clean energy. The fossil fuel industry can’t exist in a world where we’re making strides to solve climate change, but these workers can’t just be thrown to the wind. They need training and assurance that there’s a spot for them in our clean energy future.

The Navajo Nation has been looking more and more to solar in recent years. The tribe received a $94 million loan earlier this year to complete a solar farm, which has temporarily employed some members of the nation, according to a local public radio station.

Advertisement

Recovering from this loss financially won’t be easy, though. The transition toward clean energy must happen to fight climate change, especially in a community where many don’t even have electricity.

Yessenia Funes is climate editor at Atmos Magazine. She loves Earther forever.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

dnapl
Dense non aqueous phase liquid

Fun with numbers:

Navajo generating station (NGS) nameplate capacity: 2,250 MW

NGS capacity factor (how much it runs over a year in simple terms): 0.7

Utility scale solar area needs: 5 to 10 acres per MW (say 5 acres/MW given sunny Arizona)

https://www.seia.org/initiatives/siting-permitting-land-use-utility-scale-solar

Capacity factor for solar in Arizona: let’s say 0.22

Acres needed for equivelent generation:

2,250 MW x 5 acres/MW: 11,250 acres (factor in different capacity factors of coal and solar, if annual generation (MW-hours) equivelent is needed. That would increase land area need.)

Land area of NGS (includes mine and right away): about 7,500 acres (https://www.usbr.gov/ngs/)

So about nuts on for comment section energy transition.

All doable.

If wind is feasible in the area, you can add wind and batteries for a hybrid system and shrink the land area. My god there’s already transmission infrastructure for markets. That’s a huge cost and burden for Great Plains (as a remote area analogy) wind and solar. And Californians should be glad to help out the Navajo.

Plus site remediation

There’s good work in demolishing the plant, mine reclamation, waste management, and soil and groundwater remediation. Plus repurposing of railroad spur for alternative use. These are skilled and well paying jobs.