Cool Discovery Could Finally Explain Gigantic Ice Rings Found on Siberian Lake

An ice ring measuring around 3 kilometers (1.9 miles) wide on Lake Baikal, as seen on April 1, 2016.
An ice ring measuring around 3 kilometers (1.9 miles) wide on Lake Baikal, as seen on April 1, 2016.
Image: MODIS/NASA

The appearance of large ice rings on Lake Baikal in southern Siberia has confounded scientists since they were first discovered in the early 2000s. Recent investigations into the ice rings have resulted in a plausible explanation, but there’s still much to learn about these unusual features.

Advertisement

Russia’s Lake Baikal is the world’s largest and deepest freshwater lake. It’s home to many varieties of fish not seen anywhere else in the world, and even an endemic freshwater seal population. And it also features strange ice rings, which were first spotted in the early 2000s through MODIS satellite imagery.

Research published late last year in Limnology and Oceanography posits a plausible explanation for strange ice rings that frequently appear on Lake Baikal during the winter months: the circular movement of warm water beneath the ice.

Advertisement

The overall shape of an ice ring isn’t really discernable to an observer on the ground. They’re sufficiently large enough that their ring-like shape can only be seen from planes and satellites. The interior portions of the circles are bright, while the outer perimeters are dark where the ice is thin. The rings tend to be around 5 to 7 kilometers (3 to 4 miles) in diameter, while the dark, outer perimeter itself is around 1 kilometer (0.6 miles) wide, according to the new research. The rings last anywhere from a few days to a few months during the Siberian winter.

Ice rings seen on Lake Baikal and Lake Hovsgol.
Ice rings seen on Lake Baikal and Lake Hovsgol.
Image: www.icerings.org

Ice rings like this seem to be exclusive to Lake Baikal and neighboring Lake Hovsgol in Mongolia as well as Lake Teletskoye, another Russian lake about 830 miles west of Baikal. But it’s entirely possible that they exist on other lakes and just haven’t been observed yet. Their appearance tends to be unpredictable, both in terms of time and place.

The ice rings have been attributed to numerous causes, including atmospheric or biological effects, elaborate hoaxes, and even the activities of aliens. A popular theory suggests the ice rings form from leaking gas, namely methane, which bubbles up from the bottom of the lake. The rings, however, have been observed in shallow parts of the lake where gas leakages are unlikely.

Advertisement

To get to the bottom of this mystery, the authors of the new study—a collaborative team from France, Russia, and Mongolia—organized field expeditions to Lake Baikal during the winters of 2016 and 2017, and studied thermal infrared satellite imagery of the ice rings.

The team drilled holes near the ice rings, into which they dropped sensors that could measure water temperature at depths reaching 200 meters (660 feet). Measurements were taken twice each winter, once in February and then again in March.

Advertisement

This proved to be hazardous work. On March 16, 2016, the ice layer began to crumble beneath their van, requiring the driver and passengers to be rescued. It happened again just two days later.

Left: a vehicle trapped in ice along the eastern boundary of a ring. Right: a researcher exploring a ring on foot.
Left: a vehicle trapped in ice along the eastern boundary of a ring. Right: a researcher exploring a ring on foot.
Image: A. Beketov/A. Sukenv/www.icerings.org
Advertisement

In February 2016, the researchers, who refer to themselves as The Fellowship of the Ice Rings, detected an eddy—where water moves in a circular motion—at a depth of 45 meters (148 feet) beneath an ice ring. This discovery provided the team with a firsthand look at the ice conditions during the late stage of ice ring formation. The water in the eddy was found to be around 1 to 2 degrees Celsius (1.8 to 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit) warmer than the water around it, and it took about 3 days for the eddy to make a complete rotation.

A year later the team found another eddy, which migrated 6 kilometers (3.7 miles) from its original position by the end of March. No ice ring was seen above the eddy, likely because not enough time had elapsed for a ring to form above it. A similar thing was spotted in 2019, when a ring moved 9 kilometers (5.5 miles) from its initial position. The findings have led the researchers to believe the warm eddies are the primary cause of the ice rings.

Advertisement

“Results of our field surveys show that before and during ice ring manifestation, there are warm eddies that circulate in a clockwise direction under the ice cover,” Alexei Kouraev, a team member and hydrologist from the University of Toulouse, said in a recent NASA Earth Observatory post. “In the eddy center, the ice does not melt—even though the water is warm—because the currents are weak. But on the eddy boundary, the currents are stronger and warmer water leads to rapid melting.”

Ice rings on Lake Baikal as seen on April 25, 2019.
Ice rings on Lake Baikal as seen on April 25, 2019.
Image: MODIS/NASA
Advertisement

Ice ring development, according to the new research, begins in autumn before the lake is frozen. The eddies are formed from wind-churned outflows of water from the Barguzin Bay to the lake’s middle region. The scientists suspect a similar process is happening in other lakes where ice rings form.

More research will be required to fully elucidate the cause of these ice rings, but this latest study offers an exciting explanation. That said, many mysteries remain, such as why the eddies have a convex shape—a feature that’s typically seen in ocean eddies but not in lakes. Future research will also have to take the shape of the coastline into consideration, as that seems to play an important role in affecting how the eddies move.

Advertisement

In terms of other findings, the scientists found satellite photos of the ice rings that dated back to the 1960s, so these structures aren’t a new phenomenon. Even if they been around for awhile, they still show that Lake Baikal continues to be one of the coolest places on the planet. Hopefully we’ll learn more about these enigmatic ice rings soon—and not just for the science. Local residents often drive on the lake during the winter months, and these ice rings pose a real risk to vehicles. Perhaps future traffic reports will highlight the presence of dangerous ice rings and their associated thin ice.

George is a senior staff reporter at Gizmodo.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

dnapl
Dense non aqueous phase liquid

If one were to be assigned to do the investigation field work on this phenomena, at a remote Russian lake, in the middle of freaking winter - one should say it’s aliens in the hope of another assignment where it’s warmer. If one is a grad student, then one should just be happy to be doing science.

They should be able to monitor for methane generation and determine to some degree of certainty that it is or isn’t contributing to the formation of those gigantic ice rings. I’m not saying it would be easy given the lake depth and dynamic ice, possibly crushing surface equipment. But methane flux is monitored at dam reservoirs - so there’s standard flux sampling and analysis standard methods that could be re-standardized. Then if it’s not methane - it’s something else.