Another Thing Killing Coral Reefs: Our Poop

Illustration for article titled Another Thing Killing Coral Reefs: Our Poop
Photo: Greg McFall (NOAA)

It’s no secret that corals are dying at an alarming rate. While climate change heating up the oceans is understood to be screwing over corals, a new study points fingers at a different culprit: pollution.


Published in the journal Marine Biology Monday, the study used 30 years’ worth of data to conclude that nutrient pollution stemming from fertilizer and improperly treated sewage is behind coral death in the Looe Key Reef in the Florida Keys. In fact, the study authors appear to suggest in the study that pollution has been a greater detriment to the corals here than rising ocean temperatures. Climate change is simply making the situation worse.

The research includes data from 179 sampling events between 1984 to 2014. The authors looked at seawater data throughout these years where they were able to measure the amount of nitrogen, phosphorus, and other nutrients in addition to seaweed, which can indicate how nutrients are affecting the ecosystem. The researchers also looked at ocean temperature data to compare its role versus that of this pollution. Satellite imagery helped the scientists figure out how connected the different bodies of water near the reefs are to confirm where the pollution was coming from. The team, finally, used underwater photographs of the corals to determine how all this was impacting them.

By 2008, only 6 percent of Looe Key Sanctuary Preservation Area was covered with living coral—a more than 27 percent drop from 1984 levels, per the study. As it turns out, high levels of pollution coincided more strongly with disease and the death of corals than elevated ocean temperatures. During the study period, the three major coral bleaching events—where corals to eject the algae that live inside them to help produce their food—occurred after elevated pollution levels.

The study suggests excess nitrogen in the water impacts corals’ ability to survive when oceans heat up. And corals don’t even need nitrogen levels to be as high as previously thought to see impacts, the study authors found.

Much of this pollution is entering the system in the Florida Everglades, which ultimately sends this junk downstream into the reefs at Looe Key. Two periods of major coral decline—from 1985 to 1987 and 1996 to 1999—came after the Everglades received major freshwater deliveries, which reduced the water system’s salinity levels and increased nutrient enrichment.


The study illustrates that how humans manage flow of water through the Everglades is critical not only for that ecosystem, but for everything south of it, including these reefs. More importantly, it illustrates another threat to our coral reefs. We’ve found that pollution in other forms (like plastic!) is killing our reefs, but now we’re learning how a different form of pollution can lead the charge. Climate change won’t only hurt corals by warming up their home; it’s supposed to increase runoff by 19 percent globally as precipitation patterns change, a 2017 study found.

The key, the authors note, is better managing our water systems. C’mon, literal shit (be it fertilizer or sewage) don’t belong on our reefs.


Yessenia Funes is climate editor at Atmos Magazine. She loves Earther forever.


Dense non aqueous phase liquid

In fact, the study authors appear to suggest in the study that pollution has been a greater detriment to the corals here than rising ocean temperatures.

Hmmmm. This was one longass fucking paper - you know, the stuff after the abstract.

The study looked at the importance of considering multiple factors impacts on a complex system including the following: (1) nutrient loading from local (e.g. POTW discharges) and general (nutrients runoff), (2) water management (fresh water drainage cycles from a highly engineered hydrologic system), (3) nitrogen/phosphorus stoichiometry (the balance of the two and impacts on corals, (4) bacteria impact on coral health and... and.. (5) rise in ocean temperature.

They basically tried to separate out perturbing events (1 through 4) versus long term physical condition changes (5). And they seem to infer there’s cause and effect.

The authors suggested that other researchers focussed solely on temperature rise as the sole driver of coral bleaching. This paper’s authors thought that was fucking bogus, man. This research suggested looking at all interfering variables in an attempt at multivariate analysis on mother earth.

The authors did “suggest” this whole thing is juiced, given that most kinetic systems (in biology and chemistry) are temperature dependent.

Don’t try to control mother nature’s interfering variables. She’ll screw with your head, man, if you box in her complexities.

It’s all anthropogenic. There’s 7.8 billion of us fuckers fucking up the place.